Denied Workers Comp Claim

A workplace injury is already a stressful experience—pain, medical appointments, lost income, and the pressure of being away from your job. When your workers’ compensation claim is denied, it adds another layer of anxiety that no one wants to deal with.

If this has happened to you, take a breath. A denied workers’ comp claim doesn’t mean your case is over. In fact, it’s more common than most people realize. Many injured workers go through a similar process, especially in Florida, where strict guidelines and employer-driven insurance policies can make it harder to get approved the first time.

Let’s break down why claims are denied, what steps you can take next, and how we can help you navigate the process from here.

Schedule A Free Consultation

Common Reasons Workers’ Compensation Claims Get Denied

The first thing to understand is that a denial is not always personal—it often comes down to technicalities, deadlines, or documentation issues. If you were denied workers’ compensation benefits, it doesn’t mean your case is closed. Many initial denials stem from missing paperwork, late reporting, or disputes over how the injury occurred—not because your claim lacks merit. Knowing the reasons behind the denial is the first step toward correcting the issue and moving forward with an appeal.

1. You Missed the Reporting Deadline

Under Florida law, you must report your injury to your employer within 30 days of the accident (or the date you knew the injury was work-related). Missing this window can result in an automatic denial.

2. Your Employer Disputes the Claim

Sometimes, an employer may argue that your injury didn’t happen on the job or wasn’t related to your work duties. This is more common than people realize, especially if the injury wasn’t witnessed or wasn’t reported immediately.

3. There’s a Lack of Medical Evidence

If you didn’t see a doctor, delayed treatment, or didn’t follow medical instructions, your claim may be denied for “insufficient evidence.” Also, if you saw a non-approved doctor, your medical report may not count toward your claim.

4. Pre-existing Conditions Are Blamed

Insurers often try to shift the cause of your injury to a pre-existing condition, arguing that your current pain or symptoms aren’t directly related to your job injury.

5. Your Behavior Is Questioned

If the insurance company believes you were intoxicated, acting recklessly, or engaging in horseplay when the injury happened, they may deny your claim outright.

6. You Didn’t File the Claim Properly

Even simple errors—wrong dates, missing information, or filing the wrong forms—can delay or deny your benefits. There is a specific time period to file a workers’ compensation claim in Florida.

What You Can Do After a Denied Workers’ Comp Claim

A denial letter can feel like the end of the road, but you still have legal rights. The Florida workers’ compensation system has a built-in appeals process, and many claims that are initially denied are later approved with the right evidence and representation.

Step 1: Read the Denial Letter Carefully

Florida law requires the insurance company to state the reason for denial. Look closely at the explanation—it will help you understand what went wrong and what needs to be corrected or challenged.

Step 2: Gather Documentation

Start collecting all relevant documents, including:

• Medical records and diagnostic reports
• Written communication from your employer
• Witness statements
• Photos or videos of the injury site
• A timeline of events from the day of the accident

Step 3: Consult a Fort Lauderdale Workers’ Comp Attorney

Appealing a denied claim involves legal deadlines, filing procedures, and often, a hearing. Working with a Fort Lauderdale Workers’ Comp Lawyer helps ensure your case is presented clearly and persuasively. We can step in to gather evidence, handle communication, and represent you at every step.

Step 4: File a Petition for Benefits

In Florida, you must file a Petition for Benefits with the Office of the Judges of Compensation Claims (OJCC) within two years of the injury—or within one year of the last medical benefit received. The petition formally starts your appeal. To receive workers’ compensation benefits, you must follow these deadlines carefully. Missing them could forfeit your right to pursue any further compensation, even if your injury is legitimate and your initial denial was unjustified.

What Happens During the Appeals Process?

The appeals process in Florida is not a simple form submission—it’s a multi-stage legal process that can take weeks or months. Here’s what to expect:

1. Mediation

After your petition is filed, the first step is usually a mediation session. A neutral third-party mediator will work with both sides to try to reach a settlement.

2. Pretrial Hearing

If mediation fails, a pretrial hearing will be scheduled. This is where the judge will review your case, ask for documents, and set the ground rules for the next phase.

3. Final Hearing

At the final hearing, both sides will present evidence, testimony, and legal arguments. A workers’ comp judge will make the final decision. This is where having legal representation becomes critical.

4. Possible Appeals to Higher Courts

If the judge denies your appeal, you can take the case further by appealing to the First District Court of Appeal. However, this level of appeal is more technical and requires in-depth legal knowledge.

What Benefits You Could Still Be Entitled To

Even if your claim was denied, that doesn’t mean you aren’t owed compensation. Once your claim is approved, benefits may include:

• Medical expenses – Including surgeries, physical therapy, medications, and long-term care
• Wage replacement – Temporary Total Disability (TTD), Temporary Partial Disability (TPD), or Permanent Total Disability (PTD) payments
• Mileage reimbursement – For travel to and from medical appointments
• Vocational rehabilitation – If you can’t return to your previous job
• Death benefits – For surviving family members in fatal accident cases

These benefits can make a meaningful difference in your recovery and financial stability.

Can You Work While Appealing a Denied Claim?

One of the most common questions injured workers ask is whether they can return to work while their appeal is pending. The answer depends on your medical condition, the nature of your job, and whether a doctor has cleared you to return in some capacity.

If your treating physician releases you for light-duty work and your employer can accommodate your restrictions, you may be allowed to return—but this can affect your claim. Insurance carriers may argue that your ability to work means your injuries aren’t severe, potentially undermining your appeal.

Before returning to work in any form, it’s wise to speak with a Fort Lauderdale Workers’ Comp Lawyer to understand how it may impact your case and ongoing benefits.

What to Do If Your Employer Retaliates After a Denied Claim

It’s illegal in Florida for an employer to retaliate against a worker for filing a workers’ compensation claim. Unfortunately, retaliation still happens—especially after a claim is denied. Some employees face demotion, reduced hours, or even termination under questionable circumstances.

If you believe your employer is punishing you for pursuing your claim or appeal, document everything. 

Keep copies of performance reviews, emails, and any communication related to your job duties or changes in employment status. Then contact a Fort Lauderdale Workers’ Comp Lawyer immediately. You may have grounds for a separate legal claim related to unlawful retaliation.

Do Denied Claims Impact Future Job Opportunities?

Another concern many workers have is whether a denied claim will affect future employment. The truth is, your current or potential employer should not base hiring or job assignments on your workers’ comp history. In most cases, your claim—and even the denial—remains confidential and should not be disclosed in background checks.

That said, if your injury results in long-term limitations or medical restrictions, you may need to disclose those during the hiring process if they affect your ability to do the job. If you’re worried about this, we can help you understand your rights under Florida and federal employment law, including protections under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

How Surveillance and Social Media Can Affect Your Case

Once your claim is denied and moves into the appeals phase, it’s common for insurance companies to become more aggressive. One tactic they use is surveillance. Investigators may watch your home, follow you in public, or monitor your activities on social media.

If you post pictures or updates that seem to contradict your injury—like lifting something heavy, going on vacation, or even smiling at a party—insurers may use it to argue that you’re not really injured. Even if the content is harmless or taken out of context, it can hurt your case.

We advise all clients to limit social media use and be aware that their actions may be monitored while a case is pending.

Why Hiring a Lawyer Early Can Help Prevent Denials

Many workers wait until their claim is denied to contact a Fort Lauderdale Workers’ Comp Lawyer, but the truth is, getting legal help early can increase your chances of approval in the first place. From properly filing forms to coordinating medical care and dealing with employer communication, having guidance from the start helps avoid mistakes that can later lead to denial.

An experienced workers’ compensation attorney knows what documentation is needed, how to speak with the insurance company, and how to identify red flags that could put your claim at risk. If your case is already denied, we can step in immediately to review the file, build your appeal, and represent you in hearings or mediation. What does a workers’ compensation attorney do? They take the pressure off you, handle the legal legwork, and make sure your rights are protected every step of the way—so you can focus on recovery instead of fighting with insurance carriers.

What Happens If Your Condition Worsens After a Denied Claim?

Sometimes, an injury that seems manageable at first becomes more serious over time. You may have filed a claim, been denied, and tried to move forward—but now you’re dealing with new pain, complications, or even a secondary injury related to the original one.

If your condition has worsened, you may still have options, even after an initial denial. Florida law allows you to seek additional medical evaluations or updated documentation that reflects your current medical state. With this new evidence, you may be able to reopen your claim or strengthen your appeal.

Medical conditions evolve, and the system does account for that—especially if new medical records show that your injuries are more significant than originally documented. We can help gather this information and submit it effectively during the appeals process.

When a Denial Feels Personal—We’re Here to Help

We’ve worked with many clients who were honest, hardworking people—yet their claims were denied for reasons that didn’t make sense. Some were told their pain wasn’t real. Others were accused of exaggerating symptoms. A few were even told they didn’t have the “right kind of injury” for benefits.

If that sounds like your experience, we understand the frustration. We’re not here to judge—we’re here to help. Your health, financial security, and dignity matter, and we take pride in standing up for people who feel overlooked or pushed aside by the system.

About the Law Offices of David M. Benenfeld, P.A.

At the Law Offices of David M. Benenfeld, P.A., we’ve spent decades helping injured workers across South Florida get the support and compensation they need after workplace accidents. 

We understand how frustrating and overwhelming it is to have your workers’ comp claim denied, especially when you’re already in pain and trying to recover.

Our team is committed to guiding you through every step of the legal process. From reviewing your denial and filing appeals to representing you in hearings, we handle the tough conversations so you can focus on healing. Whether you’re in Fort Lauderdale, Sunrise, or West Palm Beach, we’re here to fight for your rights and make sure your voice is heard.

Need Help After a Denied Workers’ Comp Claim?

If you’re in Fort Lauderdale or anywhere in South Florida and your workers’ comp claim has been denied, it’s not too late to act. At the Law Offices of David M. Benenfeld, P.A., we help injured workers navigate denials, appeals, and everything in between. 

We know the tactics insurance companies use—and we know how to respond.

You don’t need to face this process alone. Let’s talk about your options, review your denial, and fight for the benefits you deserve.

Call us today at (754) 254-5790 for a free consultation.

Schedule A Free Consultation